Movies Similar to Disasterpiece Theater: It's Only A Game

Frankie(2023)

Twenty years ago a strange boy named Frankie was constantly tormented by the mean girls of his class. And they say, that on the night of the Prom, Frankie tragically died from a final prank gone wrong. And now every year since, his tortured spirit chooses the meanest girl from school and signs her yearbook. And, as the story goes, if the girl he chooses doesn’t call to confess her soul to him, then he will come after her and...

The Barn Part II(2022)

The Halloween ban is now lifted in Helen's Valley, and the sorority girls of Gamma Tau Psi place Michelle in charge of their annual haunted house. Unfortunately for Michelle some uninvited trick or treaters from her past come knocking.

Metempsychosis(2024)

The trippy and terrifying past of a psychedelic rock band comes back to haunt them at a remote mountain lodge.

Hi! You Are Currently Being Recorded(2024)

On a trip to Los Angeles to visit a new flame, Anna finds herself lost, stoned and alone… or is she?

The Occurrence(2025)

A man named James battles his dark twisted mind.

Imagining Argentina(2003)

Set during the unsettling disappearances in Buenos Aires during the dictatorship of the 1970s, the film involves theater director Carlos Rueda and his wife Cecilia. Shortly after Cecilia writes an editorial commentary questioning the mysterious abductions, she is herself abducted and taken into police custody.

Sinister 2(2015)

A young mother and her twin sons move into a rural house that's marked for death.

The Atoning(2017)

Vera, Ray, and Sam, a seemingly normal family, are haunted by more than mere ghosts. The lingering horror of their past threatens their ability to function as a loving family until they become enlightened by a mystical encounter. From that moment on, they're thrust into a horror worse than anything they've ever experienced. Personal demons manifest and tear the family apart from the inside out as they come to terms with their past.

Sacred 2(2022)

A group of young people from Jakarta left for Cirebon with different destinations. Arla, Jojo, and Maura want to do research on their final assignment, which is assisted by a documentary filmmaker named Umay. Meanwhile, Ajil and Keanu are horror YouTubers who create content to maintain their existence. Their journey becomes wild and uncontrollable after meeting Ute, an indigo who has a secret agenda.

Ens Rationis(2019)

Ten years ago Vivian struck a pact with a mysterious stranger who promised her something no one else could. Tonight, she abandons the love of her life to make a remote rendezvous and settle her debt.

Care(2024)

The video follows the story of Hana's murder, moving backward in time from the moment the cops discover her discarded head to the moment right before her death.

Goodnight Killer

Horror Anthology Movie Volume 1(2013)

Six new and original tales of horror and terror!

Affirmation(2024)

A church service is interrupted by a father who blames his daughter for all the evil in the world.

The Wallet(2024)

A man leaves his annoying friend’s house and is confronted by a guy who thinks he dropped his wallet.

Larrica Tesis(2024)

Larri has been in a lot of stress, that's because he needs to conclude his thesis, nevertheless a demon will start to torment him

Masks: Sentient(2013)

Steve and Marcus were best friends in high school. They now lead very different lives, but meet again at a Halloween party long after they graduated. After venturing to Marcus' secluded family home deep in the woods, their lives unravel with deadly consequences.

The Door(2024)

Two siblings were relaxing during a rainy day when suddenly someone knocked on the door. They were curious until something happened.

The Closet

The year is 2022 and under mandate from the new city Mayor, a supernatural closet has been fitted into all New York resident's apartments. Now they must learn to embrace it, or wish it away.

At First Light(2018)

High school senior Alex has an encounter with mysterious lights that appear over her small town. She soon develops dangerous, supernatural abilities, and turns to her childhood friend Sean. The authorities target them and a chase ensues as officials try to discover the truth behind Alex's transformation.