Movies Similar to Kidnapped in a Small Town

Petals on the Wind(2014)

This sequel to Flowers in the Attic picks up 10 years after Cathy, Chris and Carrie managed to escape Foxworth Hall.

By Appointment Only(2007)

Recently widowed estate agent Val Spencer's hopes of a big sale are interrupted when the house owner disappears and she becomes embroiled in a murder hunt.

4.6

My Husband's Baby(2024)

A famous married couple’s life is turned upside down when a mysterious pregnant woman shows up claiming to be carrying the husband’s child.

6.8

Girl Followed(2017)

A resentful 14-year-old girl is drawn into a seemingly innocent friendship with an older man, but the relationship turns sinister.

6.0

Daughter for Sale(2017)

When a runaway teenager is kidnapped by sex traffickers, her mother, a newly appointed judge, has to find and rescue her before they ship her overseas and sell her into sex slavery.

4.9

Date at Your Own Risk(2025)

Eva is part of an online community where women can openly share stories of their negative dating experiences with specific men in order to warn others. Eva finds a post about her ex-fiance Will and confronts him.

4.0

Match, Meet, Murder(2025)

A recently single lingerie designer finally dives into the world of dating apps, and meets a handsome stranger. But soon she finds there was a secret he failed to mention on his profile.

5.0

The Baby Swindler(2023)

Before the death of her husband, Susie froze an embryo. Surrogate Lorna agrees to carry the child to help Susie. Danger begins to follow Susie and when Lorna disappears, she'll do all she can to save the life of her unborn child.

5.3

Murder in Nashville(2025)

Eden Perry, a talented young musician with big dreams, leaves behind her small-town roots and moves to Nashville, the heart of country music.

0.0

Amish Abduction(2019)

Amish wife and mother Annie faces a crisis when her husband leaves the word of the Amish to live among “normal Americans,” or the “English” as the Amish dub them. But things turn even more dire when her husband returns, seeking custody of their son, and is willing to kill to achieve his goal…

5.7

Expecting Amish(2014)

Expecting Amish tells the story of 18-year-old Hannah Yoder, who is ready to join the Amish Church and marry her boyfriend Samuel. But things change when she goes to Hollywood and gets a glimpse of the world beyond.

6.6

Flowers in the Attic(1987)

After the death of her husband, a mother takes her kids off to live with their grandparents in a huge, decrepit old mansion. However, the kids are kept hidden in a room just below the attic, visited only by their mother who becomes less and less concerned about them and their failing health, and more concerned about herself and the inheritence she plans to win back from her dying father.

6.3

My Amish Double Life(2025)

By day Emma is a good Amish girl, but by night she sneaks out with her Amish friend, Rebecca, and together they lead a double life, going to clubs, flirting with boys, and falling in love in the forbidden “English” world. When Emma accidentally witnesses a murder while out, her life and community is thrown into peril.

5.6

Babysitter's Black Book(2015)

When her parents' financial problems threaten Ashley's dreams for college, the high school whiz kid takes matters into her own hands. She and her girlfriends turn their babysitting business into a wildly successful escort service for dads. But in this small suburban community, nothing stays secret for long.

5.5

Captive Hearts(2005)

A newly hired executive for a multinational corporation is kidnapped at gunpoint. His wife and a detective uncover a much more sinister international conspiracy.

5.2

Abduction Runs in the Family(2022)

Alyssa Manning was abducted as a small child and spent seven years living with her kidnapper before she was returned safely to her parents.

6.8

Client Seduction(2014)

A high-profile defense attorney determined to change her image takes on a pro bono case, which soon threatens both her and her family.

4.5

The Au Pair Nightmare(2020)

Trying to escape the pain from the death of her fiancé, a woman becomes an au pair in a house where she learns the family is hiding a mysterious secret.

4.6

Kidnapped by a Killer: The Heather Robinson Story(2025)

This is the TRUE STORY of how Heather Robinson grew up in a loving family in Illinois and, by the time she was a teen, had long known that she had been adopted as an infant. But in 2000, the then-15-year-old’s world was shattered when she learned that the man she knew as her uncle, John Robinson, was actually a serial killer accused of murdering multiple women in the Kansas City area, including her biological mother. Following her uncle’s arrest, Heather learns the shocking truth about her birth mother’s disappearance.

6.3

The Thirteenth Wife: Escaping Polygamy, Part 1(2025)

Rena Chynoweth is thrust back into her dark past when a violent massacre, tied to the cult she was formerly part of, makes headlines. As a journalist probes her for the truth, Rena recounts her forced marriage to the cult’s abusive leader Ervil LeBaron, and her journey through manipulation, violence, and survival. With the weight of her past threatening to consume her new life, she is forced to face her role in the cult’s crimes and must decide whether to expose the truth or retreat into silence.

6.0