Movies Similar to Amityville: Horror or Hoax

Amityville - The Resurgence(2022)

When paranormal investigator Sean Austin decides to do some spirit box sessions in front of the DeFeo grave and the Amityville Horror House, the responses he gets are more than he bargained for. This documentary focuses on Sean Austin's personal paranormal experiences having to do with the notorious murder and haunting case. Ralph Sarchie (Writer of Deliver Us From Evil) witnessed firsthand with Sean some of the paranormal evidence that was captured.

2.0

The Real Amityville Horror(2005)

A haunting documentary about a normal family living in Connecticut, who, after moving into their new house, are terrorized by an evil ghost that dwells in the home.

5.9

Famously Haunted: Amityville(2021)

A Tubi original documentary that delves deeply into one of the most famous and exploited hauntings in the United States.

4.4

Amityville: The Haunting(2000)

A two-part documentary of the infamous haunted house on Long Island that inspired the motion picture "The Amityville Horror."

5.7

Amityville Christmas Vacation(2022)

Wally has won a vacation to sunny Amityville! While there he has met a woman: a GHOST woman! Can the spirit of Christmas bring these two opposites together?

4.4

Amityville: A New Generation(1993)

Keyes, a successful photographer who lives at the border of Skid Row, notices a homeless man with a strange old mirror. Immediately struck by it for reasons he cannot explain, he convinces the man to sell it to him, soon behaving in increasingly erratic and unhinged ways.

4.2

The Amityville Curse(2023)

A group of friends purchase an infamous home with the intention of flipping it, only to discover a deadly paranormal presence emanating from within the house.

4.6

The Amityville Murders(2018)

On the night of November 13th, 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. took a high powered rifle and murdered his entire family as they slept. At his trial, DeFeo claimed that 'voices' in the house commanded him to kill. This is their story.

5.0

The Amityville Exploitation(2024)

1 original film, 8 sequels, 1 remake and almost 100 scams exploring a house, of course we wouldn't be left out. A house, an event explored to exhaustion, it was time for the curse to travel to Brazil. With the worst special effects, worthy of the biggest picks in world cinema, an experience you will never forget.

10.0

Killer Poop 2: Amityville Poo(2022)

The backstory of the Killer Poop of how he became who he is and where he came from as he kills anyone he runs into.

0.0

Amityville Apt.(2025)

Forty years after the infamous house was destroyed, the town has built an apartment complex on the same property. Strange occurrences and disturbances start happening at each of the residences.

0.0

Amityville: The Evil Escapes(1989)

After moving into their matriarch's gothic seaside mansion, the Evans family soon becomes host to an uninvited demonic force in the form of a mysterious lamp that once resided in the Amityville house.

4.6

Amityville Ride-Share(2023)

There's only one destination to hell.

0.0

The Amityville Harvest(2020)

While staying at an aging manor to research its liquor-smuggling history, Christina and her documentary video team interview their spooky host Vincent—but no one can capture his image or voice on video. After shocking dreams and bloody encounters, the crew members fall under Victor’s hypnotic spell.

5.1

Amityville Death Toilet(2023)

Gregg G. Allin has a semi-successful podcast exploring paranormal events. When Amityville is overrun with a spate of toilet murders leading back to the haunted house of yesteryear, Gregg wastes no time flying into town to get some answers. With Amityville’s Mayor Dump demanding answers and an end to the killings, Gregg is perplexed because this Amityville house doesn’t seem to be that scary. Looks are very deceiving, and, after a toilet in the house mutilates Sebastian the caretaker, Gregg is forced to act. What ensues is a battle like no other where Gregg is pushed to the very limits of hell and beyond in an effort to save the town… and the world!

4.4

Amityville: Dollhouse(1996)

Bill Martin has just finished construction on a picturesque new home for his family, but unknown to him, the previously barren property was once the site of the infamous Amityville murder house, which contains demonic entities with murderous sights on the family.

4.5

Amityvillenado(2025)

In the wake of a devastating storm that destroys the infamous DeFeo house, a paranormal entity merges with a malevolent tornado, unleashing an otherworldly force upon the town of Amityville.

0.0

Amityville Apocalypse(2023)

The Amityville movies just won't die. Which is why we're giving you 20 more in this feature-length anthology, Amityville Apocalypse.

0.0

The Amityville Curse(1990)

After purchasing a property in Amityville, New York, Debbie and her husband invite three of their closest friends to help renovate. Immediately uneasy in her new surroundings, she begins experiencing shockingly vivid nightmares.

4.0

Amityville Turkey Day(2024)

A turkey from hell comes home for dinner on Thanksgiving, terrorizing the film set of an indie horror film. It's Turkey Time Mother Clucker.

2.5